|
| Tom SawyerRush |
This post has been moved here. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
!—the> |
!—the> |
!—the> |
!—charting> |
!—aural> |
!—no> |
!—100> |
![]() | Classic Rock:#1 Songs, 1962-1981 |
First of all, what is classic rock? As with any genre, it’s impossible to develop a bulletproof definition on which everyone will agree, but “classic rock” is generally considered to be music from the 1960s through ‘80s which would play on album-oriented rock stations in the 1980s. As for the years I chose to represent the genre, I chose 1962 because it marked the debut of the first Beatles’ single (“Love Me Do”) and 1981 as the end of the era because it was in that year that Billboard officially launched its AOR chart. As for an actual chart tracking these songs, there isn’t one that I’m aware of. Instead, I used more than 70 best-of-lists focused on the genre to assemble a database of more than 5000 classic rock songs. I then ranked these from 1 to 50, with those rankings corresponding to how the song might have charted back in the day. I published the results in the Dave’s Music Database book Charting the Classic Rock Hits 1962-1981, available at Amazon.
![]() I concede that this is certainly not a fullproof system as some songs have grown in stature over the years while others might have been huge out of the gate but their status has diminished over the years. It isn’t a flawless system, but it does offer some idea where these songs stand. In any event, these are the songs which might have been #1 on a classic rock chart from 1962-1981, had such a chart existed. Dates reflect when the song was released or first appeared on another song chart or album. The latter are marked with asterisks (*). Check other lists based on charts, sales, and airplay here. 1962:
1963:
1964:
1965:
1966:
1967:
1968:
1969:
1970:
1971:
1972:
1973:
1974:
1975:
1976:
1977:
1978:
1979:
1980:
1981:
Resources/Related Links:
First posted 9/11/2023. |
![]() | Mood IndigoDuke Ellington |
Writer(s): Duke Ellington, Barney Bigard, Irving Mills (see lyrics here) First Charted: February 14, 1931 Peak: 3 US, 16 GA (Click for codes to charts.) Sales (in millions): -- Airplay/Streaming (in millions): -- radio, 3.25 video, -- streaming |
Awards:Click on award for more details. |
About the Song:A New Orleans jazz musician named Lorenzo Tio, Jr. was visiting his former student, Barney Bigard, in New York. Tio shared a melody called “Dreamy Blues” which he’d written as the theme song for his group back home. Bigard asked to borrow it and worked up what would become the clarinet solo for Duke Ellington’s “Mood Indigo.” DH Ellington is credited with “composing a song of his own on top of it” DH and turning the structure upside down. Typically jazz songs were arranged with the clarinet, trumpet, and trombone from highest to lowest pitch, but Ellington flipped it around the other way. DH The approach played on his talents of “subtle sophistication” NPR and “creating an element of surprise in his compositions.” NPR Ellington worked up a recording for an October 1930 broadcast, saying, “It was the first tune I ever wrote specially for microphone transmission.” WK He said, “wads of mail came in raving about the new tune.” WK In 1931, lyrics were added. They were credited to Irving Mills, Ellington’s manager, DH but Mitchell Parish, who also wrote words for the classic “Star Dust,” claimed in a 1987 New York Times interview that he was really the one responsible. SB He also is supposedly the one who gave the song its new title, MM which “suggests the deep violet-blue of indigo.” TY1 The song was first recorded by Ellington’s Jungle Band and later under the name The Harlem Footwarmers. SB The 1931 recording became a jazz standard and “one of the most beloved recordings of all time.” DJ It was revived in 1934 with a top 20 version by Jimmie Lunceford and resurfaced again in 1954 with versions by the Norman Petty Trio (#14) and the Four Freshmen (#24). PM Over the years, the song has been recorded many times as both an instrumental and vocal piece. Among those recording it are Louis Armstrong, Tony Bennett, Cab Calloway, Nat “King” Cole, Dr. John, Ella Fitzgerald, Charles Mingus, Nina Simone, Frank Sinatra, and Dinah Washington. Resources:
Related Links:First posted 2/14/2013; last updated 9/5/2023. |
![]() | I Love YouClimax Blues Band |
Writer(s): Derek Holt (see lyrics here) First Charted: February 14, 1981 Peak: 12 US, 9 CB, 10 HR, 7 RR, 20 AC, 21 CL, 14 CN, 59 AU, 1 DF (Click for codes to singles charts.) Sales (in millions): -- Airplay/Streaming (in millions): -- radio, 14.47 video, 12.06 streaming |
Awards:Click on award for more details. |
About the Song:The Climax Blues Band formed in 1967 in Stafford, England. They found their first chart success in 1976 with “Couldn’t Get It Right,” a top-10 hit in the United States and the United Kingdom. Their only other top-40 hit was “I Love You,” which didn’t chart in the UK but reached #12 on the Billboard Hot 100. On a personal note, the song was at #2 on my first personal chart. As a response to a local radio station’s countdown of the best songs of all time, I compiled my own list. I intended to make it a one-time list of favorites, but it turned into a weekly personal chart which I maintained for a little more than a decade. The song is “a pure love song about a woman who enters a man’s life and changes his world for the better. The message of love and friendship, along with the line, ‘You got what it takes so I made you my wife,’ made the song very popular at weddings.” SF The band’s guitarist, Derek Holt, wrote the song and said, “You could say it’s for one person, but it’s quite generic….Usually songs appear from nowhere, and that one appeared in a couple of hours.” SF He explained, “It was about meeting my first wife, meeting the lady that’s going to encourage me to do what I did best, and that was be a musician, with no qualms about it. I used to go away from home, used to leave her behind, and used to come back. I was a hippie, a drinking hippie with really long hair. We had a great time – I’m meeting my wife, since then I’ve never looked back. You know, pretty much out living a dream..” SF The band didn’t respond to the song initially, saying it “was a little bit too lovey.” SF However, while working with producer John Ryan for the eventual Flying the Flag album, he was going through the group’s tracks and asked if they had any more. Holt played “I Love You” and Ryan said, “That’s a hit.” SF Holt said, “Everybody just sort of looked at each other and said, “Oh, bloody hell.” SF The song was recorded with legendary keyboardist Nicky Hopkins, who worked with the Rolling Stones. SF Resources:
First posted 9/7/2022. |
| First posted 3/26/2008; updated 9/15/2020. |
Face Value |
![]() |
Released: February 13, 1981 Peak: 7 US, 13 UK, 13 CN, 2 AU Sales (in millions): 5.0 US, 1.5 UK, 17.6 world (includes US and UK) Genre: mainstream pop-rock |
Tracks: Click for codes to singles charts.
|
Rating: 3.918 out of 5.00 (average of 15 ratings)
Quotable: Collins’ “masterpiece and one of the finest moments of the ‘80s musical landscape” – Tim Sendra, All Music Guide Awards: |
About the Album: Phil Collins spent a decade with the rock group Genesis, first as their drummer and then their singer, before launching a solo career. “He’d been wrestling with the idea of doing a solo record for years, finding great inspiration in the pain caused by an impending divorce and craving artistic independence after years of collaboration. Many of the songs ended up on Genesis’ 1980 album Duke – and ‘Against All Odds’ was pocketed for later use – but he kept enough to make an album that stands as a classic moment of ‘80s pop/rock.” AMG “Collins produced the album himself and played keyboards and drums, calling in friends and the Earth, Wind & Fire horns to fill out the songs.” AMG The “thundering drums and punchy horn arrangements…clicked with the public…launching Collins’ career as one of the biggest and most unlikely stars of the ‘80s.” AZ The album kicks off “with the bitter anthem In the Air Tonight” AMG “where Collins dryly comments, ‘If you told me you were drowning / I would not lend a hand’).” AZ It is “rightly considered one of the great heartbreak songs of all time.” AMG The album offers “a compelling churn of emotions” AZ alternating “between moody ballads and bouncily soulful tracks that try to put a smile on the pain.” AMG “His everyman style of singing translates to both types of songs; he’s just as good at wringing every drop of emotion out of the ballads as he is at sailing through the deceptive breezy tunes.” AMG “The gently sung, sweet-as-punch This Must Be Love” AMG showcases “the delight he feels in exploring a new relationship.” AZ It “gives an early respite after the lurching, bruising ‘In the Air Tonight.’” AMG “The poppier tracks, like the snappy Behind the Lines and the impossibly hooky I Missed Again, show off his skills as a hitmaker and vocalist.” AMG “The pulsing I’m Not Movin’ marries one of Collins’ catchiest melodies and airiest productions with the most forceful lyrics on the record.” AMG “On the quieter songs like If Leaving Me Is Easy, Collins’ wracked vocals leave no doubt that he’s not sugarcoating his emotional devastation as he sorts through the wreckage of his life.” AMG “The new agey Droned and the swinging Hand in Hand give the album some instrumental texture and allow a break from all the desperate emotion on display.” AMG “This range of sound and emotion is part of what helps the album succeed as much as it does; so does the feeling that Collins felt driven to make this album to help him heal. It’s not a career move or a cash grab; it’s a transmission from a wounded soul delivered with a soft touch and sensitivity. As such, it’s Collins’ most honest, most compelling work. He went on to become a huge star, with loads more hits, but Face Value stands as his masterpiece and one of the finest moments of the ‘80s musical landscape.” AMG Notes: In 2016, a deluxe edition of the album was released with eight live songs from various years and four demos from 1980 for “This Must Be Love,” “Please Don’t Ask,” “Misunderstanding,” and “Against All Odds.” |
Resources and Related Links:
|
Moving Pictures |
|
Released: February 7, 1981 Peak: 3 US, 6 UK, 1 CN, -- AU, 8 DF Click for codes to charts. Sales (in millions): 5.0 US, 0.10 UK, 5.5 world (includes US and UK) Genre: progressive rock/classic rock |
Tracks:Click on a song title for more details.Total Running Time: 40:03 The Players:
|
Rating:4.278 out of 5.00 (average of 21 ratings)
Quotable:“Not only is 1981’s Moving Pictures Rush’s best album, it is undeniably one of the greatest hard rock albums of all time.” – Greg Prato, AllMusic.comAwards:(Click on award to learn more). |
About the Album“Rush proved with Moving Pictures that there was still uncharted territory to explore within the hard rock format and were rewarded with their most enduring and popular album.” AM It “sent the band rocketing skywards.” RJ-90 “While Moving Pictures is a continuation of Rush’s musical journey, cruising closer to the commercial mainstream, there is no loss of central values.” RJ-90 “It is undeniably one of the greatest hard rock albums of all time” AM and Rush’s best album. AM Guitarist Alex Lifeson said, “It’s no exaggeration to say that this record changed our lives.” RJ-100The Canadian trio had been “a huge concert draw since the mid-1970s” RD but “while other hard rock bands at the time experimented unsuccessfully with other musical styles, Rush were one of the few to successfully” AM “respond to new wave.” RD They “streamlined their sound with seventh studio LP Permanent Waves” RD showing “that shorter songs could lead to greater radio play and exponential growth in popularity without compromising the integrity of the music.” RJ-90 The continued that approach with Moving Pictures with five of the seven songs running at about four-and-a-half minutes. RJ-90< The RecordingAfter their 1980 tour for Permanent Waves there was some discussion about making a second live album but Rush was eager to get back in the studio. By the end of August, the trio gathered in Toronto to record demos. Guitarist Alex Lifeson said, “Most of that record was written by all of us at the same time, in the room jamming with an idea and everybody going from there. What we ended up with was, I think, some of the strongest and most enduring material that we’ve ever written.” RJ-90The CoverHugh Syme “again pulled out all the stops with another superb and now iconic cover; it’s a color photograph of some picture movers moving three paintings, with the entire front scene being revealed on the back as a scene from a motion picture.” RJ-91 It was shot at the Ontario Legislative Building in Toronto. Syme won his first Juno Award (the Canadian equivalent of a Grammy) for the cover art. RJ-91Side One: Perfection“The whole entire first side is perfect.” AM “Their most renowned song, ‘Tom Sawyer,’ kicks things off.” AM However, the side also boasts radio favorites “Limelight” and “Red Barchetta” as well as the instrumental “YYZ .”Those four tracks “are absolute, peerless musical magic. Four timeless classics in a row is a triumph of songwriting, performance, production, and sequencing. All four would be a near-constant feature, to varying degrees, of every single concert and live album thereafter.” RJ-91 NotesA 40th anniversary reissue in 2022 was comprised of a five-record set that included the 2015 remaster and a previously unreleased live recording of a March 25, 1981, show at Maple Leaf Gardens in Toronto. WKThe SongsHere’s a breakdown of each of the individual songs. |
|
|
Tom SawyerRush |
Writer(s): Geddy Lee, Neil Peart, Alex Lifeson, Pye Dubois (see lyrics here) Released: May ‘81 (single), Moving Pictures (1981), Exit…Stage Left (live, 1981), Grace Under Pressure Tour (live, 1984), Chronicles (compilation, 1990), Retrospective II (compilation, 1997), The Spirit of Radio: Greatest Hits (compilation, 2003), Time Stand Still (compilation, 2010), Icon (compilation, 2010), Icon 2 (live, 2011), Rush 50 (box set, 2025) B Side: “Witch Hunt” First Charted: March 21, 1981 Peak: 44 BB, 47 CB, 57 HR, 1 CL, 8 AR, 25 UK, 24 CN, 1 DF Click for codes to charts. Sales (in millions): -- Airplay/Streaming (in millions): -- radio, 59.40 video, 413.97 streaming |
Awards:(Click on award to learn more). |
About the Song:Moving Pictures became the best-selling album of Rush’s career with sales of more than five million worldwide. It was fueled by some of its most popular songs, including “Limelight,” “Red Barchetta ,” and “Tom Sawyer.” Rush’s Geddy Lee called the latter “the quintessential Rush song” and “the one song that we have to play for the rest of our lives.” SF Indeed, it has become a staple of classic rock radio and the band’s live shows, played on every concert tour since its release. WK“Taut, muscular and full of swagger, ‘Tom Sawyer’ is still fresh, exciting, and impressive today. The guitars sound magnificent, the bass work is inventive, while Peart’s drumming explains why he topped so many music magazine polls as ‘Best Rock Drummer.’” RJ-93 The music was crafted by Lee and guitarist Alex Lifeson. The song’s “sci-fi mein is established through keen synthesizer dabbling as well as some mild background effects, while the heavy rock sound is garnered by Alex Lifeson’s guitar work and Neil Peart’s explosive drum rolls.” MD The band’s “progressive roots may be showing to a slight degree, but these elements are cubed, maintained, then added to an amiable three-minute formula.” MD Note: the song actually runs four and a half minutes. “This anthemic ode to individualism stacks virtuoso guitarist Alex Lifeson’s heavy riffs against a gleaming electronic backdrop, while [drummer Neal] Peart fires off rapid percussion rolls in support.” RD Peart wrote the lyrics with Pye Dubois of the band Max Webster based on a poem by Dubois called “Louis the Lawyer.” Peart explained that the original lyrics were “a portrait of a modern-day rebel, a free-spirited individualist striding through the world wide-eyed and purposeful.” WK Peart loosely tied it to Mark Twain’s The Adventures of Tom Sawyer SF and added the dimension of “reconciling the boy and man in myself, and the difference between what people are and what others perceive them to be.” WK |
|
|
Red BarchettaRush |
Writer(s): Geddy Lee, Alex Lifeson, Neal Peart Released: 10/22/82 (B side of “Subdivisions”), Moving Pictures (1981), Exit…Stage Left (live, 1981), Chronicles (compilation, 1990), Retrospective II (compilation, 1997), The Spirit of Radio: Greatest Hits (compilation, 2003), Rush 50 (box set, 2025) Peak: 6 CL, 3 DF Click for codes to charts. Sales (in millions): -- Airplay/Streaming (in millions): -- radio, -- video, 39.91 streaming About the Song:“’Red Barchetta’ is set in an Orwellian-style future where personal transportation has been prohibited. The first-person hero of the tale takes his uncle’s ‘brilliant red’ car from a ‘better, vanished time’ from a farm into the countryside, where he encounters two government enforcement vehicles. A chase ensues with the narrator escaping via a bridge which proves too narrow for his pursuers. He ends his day back at the farm, dreaming of possibilities with his uncle ‘by the fireside.’” RJ-94The song was inspired by the 1973 short story ‘A Nice Morning Drive’ by Richard S. Foster. Peart changes the car from an MGB Roadster to a Ferrari 166 MM Barchetta and he has the hero escape while the original version had him crashing into a tree. RJ-94 While “Red Barchetta” is the second longest song on Moving Pictures, it “doesn’t feel excessive due to the exuberance of the playing, the highly charged, melodic sections, and the involving tale. The song is close to perfection with its blend of story, numerous contrasting musical sections and extraordinary musicianship.” RJ-94 A “pastoral mood is created” at the beginning with “delicate guitar harmonics and sustained synth.” RJ-94 There is a “sunny atmosphere highlighted by Lee’s folksy singing style.” RJ-94 “Things pick up for the second half of the verse with syncopated stabs from bass and drums.” RJ-94 Eventually “the tension grows with the music and lyrics in perfect sync as the vocals conclude.” RJ-94 Then we get Alex Lifeson’s “melodic and yet wild” guitar solo. By the end, “Lee’s voice is in full rock mode…the band pushing the song to its climax as the hunted escapes, followed by a relaxing conclusion.” RJ-94 |
YYZRush |
Writer(s): Geddy Lee, Alex Lifeson, Neal Peart Released: 2/25/81 (B side of “Limelight”), Moving Pictures (1981), Exit…Stage Left (live, 1981), Grace Under Pressure Tour (live, 1984), Rush 50 (box set, 2025) Peak: 9 CL Click for codes to charts. Sales (in millions): -- Airplay/Streaming (in millions): -- radio, -- video, 63.50 streaming About the Song:“YYZ” “is a firmly focused instrumental which compresses plenty of ideas and a fantastic groove into its four-and-a-half minute duration.” RJ-95 It “remains the gold standard of advanced technique for guitarists, bassists and drummers the world over.” RJ-96“The opening sequence is based upon the rhythm of the Morse Code call sign for Toronto’s Pearson International Airport, YYZ.” RJ-95 The next section “is both rhythmically straightforward and melodically complex.” RJ-95 This if followed by guitarist Alex Lifeson’s “stunning solo…twisting and turning, fluid and flowing, he makes full use of a guitarist’s toolbox of techniques.” RJ-95 Then there’s a “more relaxed, half-time feel with the synthesizer dominating.” RJ-96 The track comes “to a tight end after a brief reinstatement of the introduction’s theme.” RJ-96 |
|
|
LimelightRush |
Writer(s): Geddy Lee, Alex Lifeson, Neal Peart Released: 2/25/81 (single), Moving Pictures (1981), Grace Under Pressure Tour (live, 1984), Chronicles (compilation, 1990), Retrospective II (compilation, 1997), The Spirit of Radio: Greatest Hits (compilation, 2003), Time Stand Still (compilation, 2010), Rush 50 (box set, 2025) B side: “YYZ ” First Charted: March 28, 1981 Peak: 55 BB, 66 CB, 67 HR, 3 CL, 4 AR, 18 CN, 2 DF Click for codes to charts. Sales (in millions): -- Airplay/Streaming (in millions): -- radio, -- video, 182.92 streaming About the Song:Limelight “examines the pros and cons of stardom.” AM Drummer and lyricist Neal Peart wrote a “confessional lyric” about “his longstanding desire for privacy and isolation.” RJ-96 Singer Geddy Lee said, “It was at a time when the band was becoming more popular. It was a different level of fame and Neal was being confronted with things on a regular basis that were making him really uncomfortable. So he wrote that lyric.” RJ-96“The combination of music and lyrics is sublime.” RJ-96 “Lee’s melodic vocal illuminates the plea for privacy.” RD “The chorus is particularly effective, starting in a relatively relaxed state…before becoming more drivingly rocky.” RJ-96 “Repeated choruses lead into a big, no, make that massive rock ending, with Peart unleashing a superlative lengthy run around his kit before the final power chord.” RJ-97 Alex Lifeson’s guitar solo is “initially grateful and relaxed [and then] it builds in ever-increasing anguish, climbing the fretboard in a sequence of arpeggios before finally disappearing with a single, sustained high note.” RJ-97 He said, it “is probably my favourite solo to play.” RJ-97 |
The Camera EyeRush |
Writer(s): Geddy Lee, Alex Lifeson, Neal Peart Released: Moving Pictures (1981) Peak: -- Click for codes to charts. Sales (in millions): -- Airplay/Streaming (in millions): -- radio, -- video, 12.16 streaming About the Song:“The mood changes dramatically for what was the second side of the vinyl release” RJ-97 of Moving Pictures. “The long and winding The Camera Eye begins with a synth-driven piece before transforming into one of the band’s more straight-ahead epics.” AM Running at nearly eleven minutes, the song is a startling change from the more concise songs from side one. “Yes, it works, but it would have benefited from some substantial editing.” RJ-98The song has “an urban rather than fantasy setting” RD “with the lyrics offering a detached, almost alienated view of city living. Peart is suggesting that city dwellers should escape the shackles of their environment and appreciate the rest of the world around them.” RJ-97 “City noises, sustained synthesizer, and agitated, military-style drumming in the background set up an inherent tension with isolated guitar contributions.” RJ-97 Vocals don’t appear until the three-and-a-half-minute mark. The focus begins on New York City and then shifts to London where “the same musical framework acts as a canvas for superb lyricism.” RJ-98 Toward the end of the song, Alex Lifeson provides “another searing, melodic solo. Initially not over-playing, he gradually introduces greater complexity and speed, culminating in a dazzling semiquaver display before giving way to the postscript of the track.” RJ-98 |
Witch Hunt (Part III of “Fear”)Rush |
Writer(s): Geddy Lee, Alex Lifeson, Neal Peart Released: May ’81 (B side of “Tom Sawyer ”), Moving Pictures (1981), Grace Under Pressure Tour (live, 1984), A Show of Hands (live, 1989), Rush 50 (box set, 2025) Peak: -- Click for codes to charts. Sales (in millions): -- Airplay/Streaming (in millions): -- radio, -- video, 8.62 streaming About the Song:This was written as “the third part of an anticipated trilogy of songs focusing on fear.” RJ-98 “A musical retelling of the 1940 novel The Ox-Bow Incident by the American writer Walter Van Tilburg Clark…Peart describes the mentality of the mob. There is no let-up or resolution to the song; unremittingly bleak and disturbing, the music is similarly relentless and tense.” RJ-98Peart said, “’Witch Hunt’ was the winner of the most rewritten song award, being very difficult to get a handle on…It would serve as a sort of vehicle for experimentation and indulgence.” RJ-98 |
|
|
Vital SignsRush |
Writer(s): Geddy Lee, Alex Lifeson, Neal Peart Released: 3/28/81 (single), Moving Pictures (1981), Grace Under Pressure Tour (live, 1984), Icon 2 (live, 2011), Rush 50 (box set, 2025) B side: “A Passage to Bangkok,” “In the Mood” Peak: 43 CL, 41 UK, 27 DF Click for codes to charts. Sales (in millions): -- Airplay/Streaming (in millions): -- radio, -- video, 16.97 streaming About the Song:Vital Signs “marries a dramatic refrain to futuristic reggae.” RD This and “Witch Hunt” are “two of the trio’s more underrated rock compositions.” AM This was “a sonic curved ball for fans, married to lyrics which display a world of possibilities for the creative individual.” RJ-99 Geddy Lee said, “Usually, on every album, there’s one song that we write spontaneously…And those songs usually end up taking us in a totally different direction, as that one did. It’s kind of a precursor for us getting more involved with sequencers.” RJ-99“It would prove to be a significant pointer for the music the band would produce for part of the new decade.” RJ-99 Neal Peart explored the theme “that technology, rather than dominating human existence, might well mimic our inherent nature, thus remaining under our control.” RJ-99 |
Resources/References:
Related DMDB Pages:First posted 4/28/2008; last updated 6/18/2026. |