A Billy Joel Retrospective, 1971-2001

Billy Joel A Retrospective: 1971-2001

Overview: He was born William Martin Joel on May 9, 1949, in New York City (the Bronx), New York. He showed an aptitude for the piano and began taking lessons at age four. When he saw the Beatles on The Ed Sullivan Show in 1964, he decided to pursue a full-time music career. After failed stints with the Echoes, the Hassles, and Attila, he went solo and “refashioned himself as a sensitive singer/songwriter.” A-B From 1971 to 1993, he released a dozen studio albums, charted 33 top-40 hits and garnered 23 Grammy nominations and 5 wins, including Album of the Year for 52nd Street and Song and Record of the Year for Just the Way You Are.” He was inducted into the Songwriters Hall of Fame in 1992 and the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 1999. He has sold over 150 million records worldwide. “Although Billy Joel never was a critic’s favorite, the pianist emerged as one of the most popular singer/songwriters of the latter half of the ‘70s.” A-B “His classical training and reverence for Broadway musicals” RH alongside a “flair for Tin Pan Alley” RH “have been counterpointed by his early grounding in the Long Island bar-band scene and his love of rhythm & blues, resulting in an enthusiastic yet musically sophisticated approach to rock and roll. His diverse influences include Beethoven, the Beatles, Dave Brubeck, George Gershwin, Phil Spector, Ray Charles and Fats Domino…From romantic balladry to hard-rocking material, with elements of jazz, pop and soul thrown into the mix, Joel has applied his skills in a diversity of settings.” RH His “popularity is such that he tied the Beatles for the most multi-platinum albums in the U.S.” RH Links DMDB encyclopedia entry for Billy Joel BillyJoel.com (official site) Wikipedia Facebook Top 50 Songs

Awards

Studio Albums

Compilations G Greatest Hits Volume I and Volume II (covers 1973-85, released 1985) G3 Greatest Hits Volume III (covers 1983-97, released 1997) UC The Ultimate Collection (covers 1973-93, released 2000) ES The Essential (covers 1973-2001, released 2001) VB Piano Man: The Very Best of (covers 1973-1993, released 2004) H The Hits (covers 1973-93, released 2010) Under each album snapshot, songs featured on the anthologies are noted. If the song charted, the date of the song’s release or first chart appearance and its chart peaks are noted in parentheses. Click for codes to charts.

Cold Spring Harbor (1971)

She’s Got a Way (11/21/81: live version, 23 US, 16 CL, 4 AC, 46 CN) G, UC, ES, VB: live You Can Make Me Free Everybody Loves You Now UC: live, H: studio Why Judy Why Falling of the Rain Turn Around You Look So Good to Me Tomorrow Is Today Nocturne Got to Begin Again

About the Album: Joel signed a deal with Family Productions and released his first solo album, Cold Spring Harbor. It went nowhere at the time, but “She’s Got a Way” would resurface in 1981 when he released a live version of the song in support of the Songs from the Attic live album. The live version of the song appears on most of the compilations cited on this page. Go to the DMDB page for more about this album.

Piano Man (1973)

Travelin’ Prayer Piano Man G, UC, ES, VB, H Ain’t No Crime You’re My Home UC, ES The Ballad of Billy the Kid Worse Comes to Worst Stop in Nevada If I Only Had the Words to Tell You Somewhere Along the Line Captain Jack G, ES

About the Album: After Cold Spring Harbor, flopped, Joel moved to Los Angeles, adopted the name Bill Martin, and started a gig as a lounge singer. He signed a new contract with Columbia Records and released Piano Man, which garnered a top-40 hit with the title cut. It was the first of 33 top-40 hits. Of course the title track is present on every possible compilation. The album also sported two minor hits with “Worse Comes to Worst” and “Travelin’ Prayer” which don’t show up on any of the compilations. Go to the DMDB page for more about this album.

Streetlife Serenade (1974)

Streetlife Serenader UC Los Angelenos The Great Suburban Showdown Root Beer Rag (instrumental) Roberta The Entertainer G, UC, ES, H Last of the Big Time Spenders Weekend Song Souvenir The Mexican Connection (instrumental)

About the Album: After the unexpected success of “Piano Man,” Joel followed quickly with another album, releasing Streetlife Serenade. He didn’t have time to develop the material as much and the album didn’t match the heights of its predecessor, but it did give him another top-40 hit with The Entertainer, “withering portrait of the music industry.” RH Go to the DMDB page for more about this album.

Turnstiles (1976)

Say Goodbye to Hollywood G, H: live; UC, ES: studio Summer, Highland Falls All You Wanna Do Is Dance New York State of Mind G, UC, ES, VB, H James Prelude/Angry Young Man I’ve Loved These Days Miami 2017 (Seen the Lights Go Out on Broadway) UC: live; ES: studio

About the Album: Joel’s move back to New York is signalled by Say Goodbye to Hollywood, a song with echoes of “Brill Building pop” RH that shows up on four of the compilations on this page – twice as the original studio cut and twice as the live version from 1981’s Songs in the Attic. The album also produced “the cabaret-styled tribute to his home turf, New York State of Mind.” RH While not a single, it became a Billy Joel fixture and appears on every compilation possible cited on this page. Go to the DMDB page for more about this album.

The Stranger (1977)

Movin’ Out (Anthony’s Song) G, UC, ES, VB, H The Stranger G Just the Way You Are G, UC, ES, VB Scenes from an Italian Restaurant G, VB Vienna Only the Good Die Young G, ES, VB, H She’s Always a Woman G, UC, ES, VB Get It Right the First Time Everybody Has a Dream

About the Album: “With its jazzy sheen and compositional cunning, Joel hit his stride” RH “and the resulting album, The Stranger catapulted him into superstardom” A-B on the backs of hits such as Just the Way You Are – which would win the 1978 Grammy for Record of the Year and Song of the Year – Movin’ Out (Anthony’s Song), She’s Always a Woman, and Only the Good Die Young. The Stranger “surpassed Simon and Garfunkel’s Bridge Over Troubled Water as the top-selling album in Columbia’s history (until Bruce Springsteen’s Born in the U.S.A. displaced it in the Eighties).” RH While Joel had three #1 hits, it is reasonable to argue that “Just the Way You Are” may be his best known song. That makes it particularly odd that it is omitted from The Hits. “Only the Good Die Young” and “She’s Always a Woman” are noticeably absent from The Ultimate Collection. Also, while the title cut is a good song, it could have been bumped from the Greatest Hits collection in favor of one of the charting songs that didn’t make the collection. Go to the DMDB page for more about this album.

52nd Street (1978)

Big Shot G, H Honesty UC, ES My Life G, UC, ES, VB, H Zanzibar Stiletto Rosalinda’s Eyes Half a Mile Away Until the Night 52nd Street

About the Album: 52nd Street spent eight weeks at number one in the U.S., eventually selling 7 million copies and landing the Grammy for Album of the Year. While lead single My Life regularly shows up on compilations, Big Shot and Honesty each only make it on two of the five possible compilations. Go to the DMDB page for more about this album.

Glass Houses (1980)

You May Be Right G, UC, ES, H Sometimes a Fantasy Don’t Ask Me Why G, UC, ES It’s Still Rock and Roll to Me G, UC, ES, VB, H All for Leyna UC I Don’t Want to Be Alone Sleeping with the Television On C’Etait Toi (You Were the One) Close to the Borderline Through the Long Night

About the Album: This was “theoretically a harder-edged album that was a response to the punk and new wave movement.” A-B This was readily apparent on Joel’s #1 hit It's Still Rock ‘n’ Roll to Me, which “rebutted punk and New Wave acts who’d taken potshots at perceived old-wavers like Joel.” RH The top-10 hit You May Be Right is inexplicably absent from Piano Man: The Very Best of. Go to the DMDB page for more about this album.

The Nylon Curtain (1982)

Allentown G, UC, ES, H Laura Pressure G, H Goodnight Saigon G, UC, ES, VB She’s Right on Time A Room of Our Own Surprises Scandinavian Skies Where’s the Orchestra?

About the Album: The Nylon Curtain was Joel’s “lushly produced concept album about America’s ‘diminishing horizons’” RH and the “baby boomers and their experiences.” A-B It was a commercial disappointment when compared to the multi-platinum success of its three studio predecessors but still spawned top-20 hits with Pressure and Allentown. How does “Pressure” only make it on to two compilations? Go to the DMDB page for more about this album.

An Innocent Man (1983)

Easy Money An Innocent Man G3, UC, ES, VB The Longest Time G, UC, ES, H This Night Tell Her about It G, UC, ES, VB, H Uptown Girl G, UC, ES, VB Careless Talk Christie Lee Leave a Tender Moment Alone UC, ES Keeping the Faith G3

About the Album: This was Joel’s “fond tribute to the doo-wop era.” RH It was a success on par with his 1977-1980 work, “eventually selling over seven million copies” A-B on the strength of six top 40 hits and his willingness to embrace MTV and music videos. Three of those – Tell Her about It, Uptown Girl, and The Longest Time – are featured on Greatest Hits Volume I and Volume II and two others – An Innocent Man and Keeping the Faith – are on Greatest Hits Volume III. Both collections passed over Leave a Tender Moment Alone, but it eventually showed up The Ultimate Collection and The Essential. Go to the DMDB page for more about this album.

Greatest Hits Volume I and Volume II Billy Joel

Recorded: 1973-1985 Released: July 2, 1985 Peak: 6 US, 7 UK, -- CN, 2 AU Sales (in millions): 11.5 US, 0.3 UK, 21.4 world (includes US and UK) Genre: rock Rating: 4.398 out of 5.00 (average of 16 ratings)

Awards: (Click on award to learn more).

Tracks, Disc 1: (1) Piano Man (2) Captain Jack (3) The Entertainer (4) Say Goodbye to Hollywood (5) New York State of Mind (6) The Stranger (7) Scenes from an Italian Restaurant (8) Just the Way You Are (9) Movin’ Out (Anthony’s Song) (10) Only the Good Die Young (11) She’s Always a Woman Tracks, Disc 2: (1) My Life (2) Big Shot (3) You May Be Right (4) It’s Still Rock and Roll to Me (5) Don’t Ask Me Why (6) She’s Got a Way (live) (7) Pressure (8) Allentown (9) Goodnight Saigon (10) Tell Her about It (11) Uptown Girl (12) The Longest Time (13) You’re Only Human (Second Wind) (14) The Night Is Still Young Total Running Time: 1:53:45 About the Album: The first Billy Joel compilation was really two albums since he released it as Greatest Hits Volume I and II and it lives up to the titles by offering two disc’s worth of hits. Beginning with Piano Man, the first disc runs through a number of early songs…including Captain Jack and New York State of Mind [that] weren’t strictly hits, but were popular numbers within his stage show.” A-G Other early favorites include “the unbridled biographical boasting of The Entertainer and the ambitious storytelling of Scenes from an Italian Restaurant,” DD an album cut from The Stranger. Mostly, though, this collection focuses on the hits, such as # 1 songs It’s Still Rock and Roll to Me and Tell Her about It as well as top ten hits like My Life , You May Be Right, and Uptown Girl. There are also his “soft-rock staples such as Just the Way You Are” DD and She’s Always a Woman. We also get “the careening abandon of Only the Good Die Young and the thoughtful social commentary of Allentown.” DD There are also two new songs: You’re Only Human (Second Wind), The Night Is Still Young. However, the collection skips top-40 hits “Honesty,” “Sometimes a Fantasy,” “An Innocent Man,” “Leave a Tender Moment Alone,” and “Keeping the Faith.” It is still “an excellent retrospective of the first half of Billy Joel’s career,” A-G “exactly why Billy Joel was one of the most popular singer/songwriters of the late ‘70s and early ‘80s” A-G and is “as complete an artist as the last three decades have produced.” DD Notes: The 1998 remastered package added videos for “You’re Only Human” and “The Night Is Still Young” and replaced the live version of “Say Goodbye to Hollywood” with the original 1976 studio version. Tracks Not on Previously Noted Albums: You’re Only Human (Second Wind) (7/13/85, 9 US, 2 AC, 26 AR, 94 UK, 15 CN, 6 AU) G, UC The Night Is Still Young (10/5/85, 34 US, 13 AC, 48 CN, 82 AU) G

The Bridge (1986)

Running on Ice This Is the Time G3, UC A Matter of Trust G3, UC, ES, H Modern Woman UC Baby Grand (with Ray Charles) G3, UC, ES Big Man on Mulberry Street Temptation Code of Silence Getting Closer

About the Album: “In the summer of 1986, Joel returned with the Top Ten single Modern Woman, which was taken from the soundtrack of Ruthless People…[and] was also a teaser from his new album, The Bridge.” A-B. It’s unclear why the song doesn’t get more love; it only appears on one compilation. The album’s place in the Billy Joel canon is similar to that of The Nylon Curtain: it was a top ten, two-million seller buoyed by a couple hits, but not on par with Joel’s multi-million sellers of the late seventies and early eighties. Go to the DMDB page for more about this album.

Storm Front (1989)

That’s Not Her Style We Didn’t Start the Fire G3, UC, ES, VB, H The Downeaster ‘Alexa’ G3, UC, ES I Go to Extremes G3, UC, ES, H Shameless G3 Storm Front Leningrad G3, UC, ES State of Grace When in Rome And So It Goes G3, ES

About the Album: Joel managed to turn “a history lesson into a hit single with his rapid-fire recitation of 20th-century names and places in We Didn’t Start the Fire…Both single and album reached #1.” RH “Storm Front marked a significant change for Joel – he fired his band, keeping only Liberty DeVito, and ceased his relationship with producer Phil Ramone, hiring Mick Jones of Foreigner to produce the album.” A-B This album is definitely over-represented on compilations. Shameless and Leningrad are good songs, but minor enough that they should be bumped from collections to make room for other more deserving hits. Go to the DMDB page for more about this album.

River of Dreams (1993)

No Man’s Land The Great Wall of China Blonde Over Blue A Minor Variation Shades of Grey All About Soul G3, UC, ES, VB Lullabye (Goodnight, My Angel) G3, ES The River of Dreams G3, UC, ES, VB, H Two Thousand Years Famous Last Words

About the Album: River of Dreams “entered the charts at number one and spawned the Top Ten title track. Following the River of Dreams tour, Joel divorced Christie Brinkley.” A-B Little did anyone know that Joel was closing another chapter as well as it marked the end of his recording career as a pop artist. Go to the DMDB page for more about this album.

The Ultimate Collection Billy Joel

Recorded: 1973-1993 Released: December 20, 2000 Peak: -- US, 4 UK, -- CN, 12 AU Sales (in millions): -- US, 0.3 UK, 0.3 world (includes US and UK) Genre: rock Rating: 4.433 out of 5.00 (average of 3 ratings)

Tracks, Disc 1: (1) Just the Way You Are (2) My Life (3) It’s Still Rock and Roll to Me (4) An Innocent Man (5) Piano Man (6) You’re My Home (7) Everybody Loves You Now (live) (8) The Entertainer (9) Streetlife Serenader (10) New York State of Mind (11) Say Goodbye to Hollywood (12) She’s Got a Way (live) (13) Movin’ Out (Anthony’s Song) (14) She’s Always a Woman (15) Honesty (16) You May Be Right (17) Don’t Ask Me Why (18) Miami 2017 (Seen the Lights Go Out on Broadway) (live) Tracks, Disc 2: (1) Uptown Girl (2) Tell Her about It (3) The River of Dreams (4) The Longest Time (5) We Didn’t Start the Fire (6) Goodnight Saigon (7) Allentown (8) All for Leyna (9) This Is the Time (10) Leave a Tender Moment Alone (11) A Matter of Trust (12) Modern Woman (13) Baby Grand (with Ray Charles) (14) I Go to Extremes (15) Leningrad (16) The Downeaster ‘Alexa’ (17) You’re Only Human (Second Wind) (18) All About Soul Total Running Time: 153:09 About the Album: I’m not a fan of the non-chronological track listing, but this non-American two-disc set does an adequate job of gathering the most familiar of Joel’s hits from throughout his career. His earliest albums receive too much attention and there are some minor hits such as “All for Lenya” and “Leningrad” that could be excised, especially since there are a handful of top 40 hits that don’t make the collection, including “Only the Good Die Young,” “Big Shot,” “Pressure,” “Keeping the Faith,” and “And So It Goes.”

Piano Man: The Very Best of Billy Joel

Released: November 15, 2004 Recorded: 1973-1993 Peak: -- US, 7 UK, -- CN, 14 AU Sales (in millions): -- US, 0.9 UK, 0.9 world (includes US and UK) Genre: rock Rating: 4.287 out of 5.00 (average of 3 ratings)

Awards: (Click on award to learn more).

Tracks: (1) Tell Her about It (2) Uptown Girl (3) Piano Man (4) New York State of Mind (5) The River of Dreams (6) It’s Still Rock and Roll to Me (7) We Didn’t Start the Fire (8) Goodnight Saigon (9) My Life (10) She’s Always a Woman (11) She’s Got a Way (live) (12) Scenes from an Italian Restaurant (13) An Innocent Man (14) Movin’ Out (Anthony’s Song) (15) Only the Good Die Young (16) All About Soul (17) Honesty (18) Just the Way You Are Total Running Time: 79:43 About the Album: This single-disc, non-American release hits the highlights, such as Piano Man, Just the Way You Are, My Life, It’s Still Rock and Roll to Me, Tell Her about It, Uptown Girl, We Didn’t Start the Fire, and The River of Dreams. Of course, the problem with a single-disc collection is how many songs get left out. For the third time, “Big Shot,” “Pressure,” and “Keeping the Faith” fail to make the cut. Also left out are top-10 hits “You May Be Right” and “I Go to Extremes,” as well as top-40 hits “Allentown,” “The Longest Time,” and “Leave a Tender Moment Alone.” To be fair, though, it’s hard to know what to bump in favor of any of these songs.

The Hits Billy Joel

Recorded: 1973-1993 Released: November 16, 2010 Peak: 34 US, -- UK, -- CN, -- AU Sales (in millions): -- US, -- UK, -- world (includes US and UK) Genre: rock Rating: 4.580 out of 5.00 (average of 3 ratings)

Tracks: (1) Everybody Loves You Now (2) Piano Man (3) The Entertainer (4) New York State of Mind (5) Movin’ Out (Anthony’s Song) (6) Only the Good Die Young (7) My Life (8) Big Shot (9) You May Be Right (10) It’s Still Rock and Roll to Me (11) Say Goodbye to Hollywood (live) (12) Allentown (13) Pressure (14) The Longest Time (15) Tell Her about It (16) A Matter of Trust (17) We Didn’t Start the Fire (18) I Go to Extremes (19) The River of Dreams Total Running Time: 79:34 About the Album: Once again, a non-American release is followed by a U.S. version. This compilation suffers from the same problem as its predecessor in that too many hits have to be overlooked to create a single-disc retrospective. The most glaring omission is “Just the Way You Are,” arguably Joel’s signature song. However, “Uptown Girl” and “A Matter of Trust” are also notably absent. Overall, though, this collection works much better than Piano Man: The Very Best of and it presents the songs chronologically.

Greatest Hits Volume III Billy Joel

Recorded: 1983-1997 Released: August 19, 1997 Peak: 9 US, 23 UK, -- CN, 12 AU Sales (in millions): 1.0 US, 0.06 UK, 1.06 world (includes US and UK) Genre: rock Rating: 3.767 out of 5.00 (average of 3 ratings)

Awards: (Click on award to learn more).

Tracks: (1) Keeping the Faith (2) An Innocent Man (3) A Matter of Trust (4) Baby Grand (with Ray Charles) (5) This Is the Time (6) Leningrad (7) We Didn’t Start the Fire (8) I Go to Extremes (9) And So It Goes (10) The Downeaster ‘Alexas’ (11) Shameless (12) All About Soul (13) Lullabye (Goodnight, My Angel) (14) The River of Dreams (15) To Make You Feel My Love (16) Hey Girl (17) Light As the Breeze Total Running Time: 76:16 About the Album: Designed as a companion to Greatest Hits Volume I and Volume II, this one, roughly, picked up where the last one left off. Keeping the Faith and An Innocent Man were from the 1983 album An Innocent Man, but everything else came after the 1985 greatest hits set. There are also two new songs and Light As the Breeze from Tower of Song, the 1995 album of Leonard Cohen covers. The rest of the collection is comprised of cuts from Joel’s three studio albums released from 1986 to 1993: The Bridge (3 songs), Storm Front (6 songs), and River of Dreams (3 songs). The Storm Front album is over-represented, especially since a few other hits, including the top-10 “Modern Woman” and top-30 “Leave a Tender Moment Alone” could have been included. Otherwise, though, it does a solid job of gathering the most familiar of Joel’s work from the latter part of his recording career. Tracks Not on Previously Noted Albums: To Make You Feel My Love (Bob Dylan) [3:53] (8/16/97, 50 US, 9 AC, 90 AU) Hey Girl (Gerry Goffin, Carole King) [3:57] (11/8/97, 13 AC) Light As the Breeze (Leonard Cohen) [6:12]

Fantasies & Delusions (2001)

Waltz No. 1 (Nunley’s Carousel) ES Invention in C minor ES

About the Album: After a dozen pop albums from 1971 to 1993, this was Joel’s foray into creating his own classical compositions. It is, to date, his last studio album.

The Essential Billy Joel

Recorded: 1973-2001 Released: October 2, 2001 Peak: 15 US, 157 UK, -- CN, 50 AU Sales (in millions): 3.0 US, 0.1 UK, 3.1 world (includes US and UK) Genre: rock Rating: 4.480 out of 5.00 (average of 3 ratings)

Awards: (Click on award to learn more).

Tracks, Disc 1: (1) Piano Man (2) You’re My Home (3) Captain Jack (4) The Entertainer (5) Say Goodbye to Hollywood (6) Miami 2017 (Seen the Lights Go Out on Broadway) (7) New York State of Mind (8) She’s Always a Woman (9) Movin’ Out (Anthony’s Song) (10) Only the Good Die Young (11) Just the Way You Are (12) Honesty (13) My Life (14) It’s Still Rock and Roll to Me (15) You May Be Right (16) Don’t Ask Me Why (17) She’s Got a Way (live) (18) Allentown Tracks, Disc 2: (1) Goodnight Saigon (2) An Innocent Man (3) Uptown Girl (4) The Longest Time (5) Tell Her about It (6) Leave a Tender Moment Alone (7) A Matter of Trust (8) Baby Grand (with Ray Charles) (9) I Go to Extremes (10) We Didn’t Start the Fire (11) Leningrad (12) The Downeaster ‘Alexa’ (13) And So It Goes (14) The River of Dreams (15) All About Soul (16) Lullabye (Goodnight, My Angel) (17) Waltz No. 1 (Nunley’s Carousel) (18) Invention in C minor Total Running Time: 154:43 About the Album: After the non-American release of The Ultimate Collection, The Essential was the first U.S. double-disc anthology covering Joel’s entire recording career. The album works through his major hits chronologically from Piano Man through The River of Dreams. There are still notable songs missing (three of which weren’t on The Ultimate Collection either), like “She’s Always a Woman,” “Big Shot,” “Pressure,” “Keeping the Faith,” “Modern Woman,” and “This Is the Time.” Like The Ultimate Collection, minor hits All for Leyna and Leningrad take up space where some of those bigger hits could have been. This is also the only one to include cuts from Joel’s 2001 classical album Fantasies & Delusions, but that’s not necessarily a positive since they aren’t familiar to the average Joel fans. Notes: A reissue added a third disc with seven songs: “Worse Comes to Worst,” “Prelude/Angry Young Man,” “Scenes from an Italian Restaurant,” “Big Shot,” “All for Leyna,” “Pressure,” and “This Is the Time.”

Resources/References: DD Daniel Durchholz, Amazon.com review by of Greatest Hits Volume I and Volume II A-B Stephen Thomas Erlewine, All Music Guide bio of Billy Joel A-G Stephen Thomas Erlewine, All Music Guide review of Greatest Hits Volume I and Volume II RH Rock and Roll Hall of Fame bio Related DMDB Links: First posted 9/22/2020; last updated 2/11/2026.